When the State Knows Where You Are, But Not Who You Are
There is a simple question hidden inside a powerful piece of political satire : How efficiently can the state find an ordinary citizen when it wants something from them—and how efficiently can it find that same citizen when the citizen wants something from the state? The difference can sometimes be striking. When it comes to collecting taxes, the system knows where you live. When an instalment is overdue, reminders arrive. When a traffic violation is recorded, the challan can reach your phone. When a government fee, penalty or licence payment is due, the machinery of administration can often identify the person responsible. In other words, when compliance is required, the citizen is rarely invisible. But democracy demands something more than compliance. A citizen is not merely a taxpayer, vehicle owner, consumer or beneficiary of government schemes. A citizen is also a voter, a participant in public life and a person with constitutional rights . That is where the cartoon's ...